‘La dictadura perfecta’: some thoughts

These days in Mexico, if you say “La dictadura perfecta”, you are likely to be understood as referring to a movie. Its title intrigued me, even if I had not heard before of Mario Vargas Llosa, the Peruvian writer who is credited with describing Mexico as the perfect dictatorship in 1990. Nor did I know of film directors Jose and Luis Estrada. So I watched the film with my wife tonight, without prejudice.

Afterwards, Irma explained how the satire related to events that have been public knowledge in the past few years. The movie is disturbing, if you engage. Yet, the film’s own making and circulation in Mexico poses an interesting challenge to the idea of the perfect dictatorship it portrays. Luis Estrada attacks directly President Peña Nieto. I note that such polemic is not unusual here. To give another example I came across today, I translate the following description printed in a national paper:

he has only been an instrument created from a network of interests and individuals that were able to bring him to the Presidency knowing his enormous intellectual limitations, his total ignorance of the country, his lack of vision, his complexes and insecurities, his evident inability to govern and, even so, they conspired on the back of the nation to materialise their objective…

The above suggests a certain liberty of expression, which, in my experience, is not present in the U.S.A or Great Britain and which contradicts the notion of Mexico being a perfect dictatorship. At the same time, the film shows a governor shooting one of his associates because they leeked a document, seconds after inviting a journalist on his payroll to witness the murder “so that he learns how things are done”. With this and many other examples Luis Estrada suggests that those in power see as the best means for maintaining themselves to power either the corruption with money or the physical elimination of those who still have morals and stand up for justice. In this sense, the film also argues that “details” can be ignored by the big bosses, so its own presence could be accepted as long as it doesn’t destabilise the status quo.

How much of this caricature to believe? The movie asks who has the real power: the politician or the controller of mass media? I’d say one needs to dig even deeper than where Estrada has reached, as both the politician and the TV-director play to the tune of their funders (who never appear on scene). It is those links where any society that respects itself should set rules and limits. And as the movie never touches on the issue of “solutions”, it may be clasified as ‘safe’, despite its edging, cutting satire.

Screen Shot 2015-04-27 at 10.08.29 PMFor those who care for social progress in Mexico, there is much work left…

If you read Spanish, I suggest the following mix:

El cabo suelto de la dictadura perfecta por Fernanda Solórzano (Letras Libres)

‘La dictadura perfecta’: mas allá de la película por Mario Maraboto (Forbes México)

La dictadura perfecta | La crítica por Alonso Díaz de la Vega (Excelsior)

La dictadura perfecta por Alfonso Flores-Durón y M. (EnFilme)

For more in english: the economist published Political Satire in Mexico

2 thoughts on “‘La dictadura perfecta’: some thoughts

  1. I read Buñuel’s autobiography, where he describes mid-to-late 20th century Mexico. As with the Estradas & Llosa, I could have taken word-to-word his description and apply to my own experience of the country during the past five years. A mountain of contrasts, he starts with the problems (I think because he cares, they pain and trouble him, the descriptions are there to help Mexicans consider their situation, which they understand better & deeper than us visitors, but perhaps take too much for granted & deeply routed in their history/culture). He then continues with a comparison of how injustice manifests itself in a structurally hidden form in more industrialised/technologically advanced countries often producing greater inequality and larger-scale crimes, which are inconceivable in Mexico. Then he praises the many virtues of Mexico, a mix of different wild flowers blooming in Spring (these are my words), and thanks the country for enabling him to direct & produce his movies.

    Re: contemporary journalist killings, I signed this petition
    https://www.change.org/p/epn-fin-a-los-asesinatos-de-periodistas-y-la-impunidad-en-m%C3%A9xico-justicia-por-javier-valdez

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s